ByDONALD LUSKIN
THE PRICE OF
oil touched all-time highs above $119 a barrel this week. Gasoline is selling for over $4 a gallon.
The bears said the housing collapse would throw the country into recession. They said the credit crisis would throw the whole world into recession. And now, seeing that oil is the global economy's single most important strategic commodity, the bears are arguing that today's prices just have to mean a global depression.
But a funny thing happened on the way to the end of the world.
While oil has surged to all-time highs over the last month, world stock markets have surged as well. Even sectors that are sensitive to energy prices have done great. In fact, the most sensitive of all, the transportation sector, made all-time highs last week. If a depression is coming, someone forgot to tell these markets.
Or maybe oil prices don't quite work the way the bears think they do.
Most people think of the price of oil as an external force acting on the economy as though it had a will of its own. If the oil price goes up (for whatever reason), that's bad because it raises the cost of doing business and the cost of living. If the oil price goes down (for whatever reason), that's good because it lowers those same costs.
Sometimes oil does have that kind of effect. On those rare occasions when there is an unpredictable supply interruption as during the Arab embargo of the 1970s or the Gulf War of the 1990s the price shoots up and it's very bad news for energy consumers. But that's the exception, not the rule.
Mostly oil behaves like any other good in the economy. It is subject to all the same laws of supply and demand. When economic growth supports more demand for oil, that demand drives up the price. At some point, the price gets high enough so that further demand is discouraged.
That means that when the price of oil rises to $119, it's because we want it, and can afford it, at that price. If we didn't, then it wouldn't trade at that price in the first place.
So high oil prices don't kill growth. In fact, they are the result of growth.
Let's look at what's happened over the last five years, from 2002 to 2007. During that period, the price of gasoline almost tripled. But at the same time, gross domestic product grew by almost 33%.
In fact, even gasoline consumption itself grew, too, despite the tripling of price. Over those five years, per capita gasoline usage grew almost 4%.
Why? Because oil prices are the result of growth. During those five years, per capita disposable personal income grew by more than 25%. Gasoline prices went up, and we bought more of the stuff, not less because we wanted it, and we could afford it.
Now perhaps you're saying, well, it's not just oil and gasoline. Prices of energy in all forms have been soaring.
So let's look at things a little more broadly. In 2002, the average American spent $1,200 a year on energy goods and services of all kinds, according to the Bureau of Economic Analysis. By the end of 2007, that had risen to $2,100 an increase of a whopping 73%. But still, that's just $900. And over the same period, average disposable income rose from $27,200 a year to $34,100. That's a smaller percentage gain, of about 25%. But it's $6,900 which means $6,000 left over after you've paid the higher cost of energy.
Perhaps you're thinking that the real issue here is not economic growth driving the oil price higher, but the fact that the world is running out.
That's absurd on the face of it. There are no shortages. There's plenty of oil for anyone who will pay the price.
You think we're running out of reserves? Go tell that to the giant oil company Petrobras, which just discovered a massive new field that looks like it's going to make Brazil into the new Saudi Arabia.
Maybe you're thinking that the high oil price is actually the result of the falling value of the U.S. dollar. No let me put it the way the media always does: the collapsing dollar, the plummeting dollar, the plunging dollar.
Before you make any bets based on that theory, though, you might want to check the facts. The dollar hasn't been collapsing, plummeting, plunging or even falling lately. Actually, it's been in a narrow trading range for the last two months. Yes, it's been weak versus the euro, but very strong versus the yen and the pound it has all pretty much balanced out.
Or perhaps you are thinking that the current high oil price is the result of speculation, not economic fundamentals. Are a handful of greedy hedge funds distorting the price, and threatening the global economy in the process?
There may be some element of this at work, though it's hard to know for sure. But I'm not that worried about it, because speculators can never distort a market for very long especially one as big as the world oil market.
How about inflation? Is that behind high oil prices? Yes and no. It has been, as I've been writing in this column for several years. But it is no longer. After the rescue of Bear Stearns last month, the Federal Reserve has reversed its inflationary course. It's gone from being a huge factor to a minor factor.
So let's say that something like $10 or $15 of the current oil price is just speculative froth or the result of dead-enders who haven't figured out that the dollar and inflation aren't problems any more. It wouldn't surprise me one bit to see the price come off by that much or more over the next month or so.
But oil would still be over $100, so there'd still be plenty to be scared about if you want to cling to the idea that a high oil price will kill economic growth.
But remember which way the lines of cause and effect really run. Growth determines the oil price. The oil price doesn't determine growth. This economy is recovering from the soft spot it's been in yes, a soft spot, not a recession and oil isn't going to stop it.
Also See:
Note: Due to an editing error, an incorrect stock symbol for Petrobras was used in the original version of this story. The correct ticker is PBR.>
Donald Luskin is chief investment officer of Trend Macrolytics, an economics consulting firm serving institutional investors. You may contact him at don@trendmacro.com.>



- LinkedIn
- Fark
- del.icio.us
- Reddit
X