Dirty Companies Try to Clean Up Their Acts

AMERICAN ELECTRIC POWER

The Ohio utility's power plants, which run mostly on coal, emitted more carbon dioxide, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxide and mercury than any other electric utility's in the country as recently as 2001, according to the Connecticut Retirement Plans & Trust Funds, a large shareholder. Sierra Club and Public Citizen sued American Electric in 2005, saying the company "seems to think that violating the Clean Air Act is good for business."

Fast forward a few years later, though, and what once were enemies now look like allies well, almost. American Electric is investing millions in environmentally friendly projects from wind generation to carbon offsetting. Sierra Club's monthly magazine, meanwhile, printed an article last year headlined, "Can Coal Be Clean?" and noted American Electric as being willing to invest in a new cleaner-coal technology despite the costs.

Whether it's for public-relations reasons or to protect business interests, or both, more companies not considered green in the past are joining the movement. These businesses are launching major environmental initiatives as pressure mounts for Corporate America to be not just profitable but also socially responsible. They're also winning over would-be foes who concede that the meaning of "green" is changing to include more than organic food and alternative energy.

"We believe no company is good or bad, and any company can be redeemed," says Julie Tanner, of Christian Brothers Investment Services, a Catholic investment firm with more than $4 billion in assets under management that urges companies to change their environmental policies. "It's hard to compliment inherently dirty industries like electric or mining, but sometimes companies under the most pressure are also doing some of the most innovative work."

There's no question the heat is on for big business. Activist investors filed a record 54 shareholder resolutions on global warming this year, according to the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, a large group of faith-based institutional investors. The targeted companies include electric utilities, oil and coal producers, airlines and home builders. Some companies, such as utility giants Dominion Resources and Southern, were quick to bow to the pressure, while others were holding out as of early March, including Exxon Mobil and US Airways Group.

"The definition of an environmental company has evolved to cut across sectors," says Eric Becker, a manager of the Green Century Balanced Fund, which invests in companies it considers committed to protecting the environment. "Companies with their heads in the sand are going to fall behind."

Becker points to industrial carpet manufacturer Interface, of Atlanta, as an example of a nontraditional but very green company. Carpet manufacturing consumes a lot of energy and water, and like other industrial businesses, emits chemicals into the environment. But Interface has a plan in place to eliminate any negative effects it has on the environment by 2020, by investing in renewable technologies and using biodegradable or recycled materials in its carpets. So far, it says it has cut the amount of manufacturing waste it sends to landfills by 70%, reduced energy use at its carpet factories by 45% and cut greenhouse gas emissions by 37% since 1996.

Newmont Mining, one of the world's largest gold producers, is also winning unlikely plaudits for its efforts to improve its environmental reputation. It was only last year that a Newmont executive in Indonesia faced potential jail time amid complaints by local villagers that pollution from a company mine was causing health problems. An Indonesian court absolved Newmont and its executive of any wrongdoing. Newmont has also faced major protests in Peru. In response to shareholder pressure, Newmont is now working with independent advisors including members of environmental group Earthworks and nongovernmental organization Oxfam America, to improve its relationship with local communities, including becoming more environmentally conscious.

"Until the world is ready to say, 'I don't want gold,' you've got to at least look at companies in the industry who are doing some good stuff," says Tanner, of Christian Brothers.

Businesses launching these eco-friendly initiatives say doing so creates shareholder value because it increases competitiveness and efficiency. "We want to be the gold company of choice," says Newmont spokesman Omar Jabara. "We want to increase our chances of being able to develop gold resources. We can do well as a business, while doing good."

For some environmentalists, this may sound like "green washing." But for others, pushing major industrial businesses to be greener is a realistic way to effect change. "We tend to be seduced by ideas like windmills, but what we don't think about is how reconfiguring all the heating and ventilation units in Las Vegas might be cheaper and make more business sense," says Lisa Margonelli, a fellow at the New America Foundation, a public policy think tank, who researches environmental and energy issues.

"If the U.S. is wasting $50 billion on industrial energy, then there's obviously a lot of money to be made by the people who figure out how to capture it," Margonelli says. She cites materials companies such as Dow Chemical and DuPont as having been "extremely successful" at reducing their energy use.

Dow says between 1995 and 2005 it cut enough energy use to power eight million U.S. homes for one year. It also says it has reduced its greenhouse gas emissions by 20% since 1990. DuPont says its global energy consumption is down 6% since 1990 despite a 41% increase in production. It says it has reduced greenhouse gas emissions 60% since 1990.

But does all this really benefit shareholders?

The Free Enterprise Action Fund is a $12 million mutual fund founded to directly challenge social activists' efforts. Steven Milloy, a managing partner of the fund, says these efforts are about politics not economics, and that companies should focus on lawfully maximizing profits rather than appeasing social activists. One of Milloy's main targets is General Electric, which he says has lobbied for environmental regulations that would hurt its own earnings.

On the business side, Cypress Semiconductor Chief Executive T.J. Rodgers famously caused a stir in 1996 by taking to task a Catholic nun's views of his company's social responsibility to have a more diverse board. Rodgers says that pushing corporations to be more socially responsible prevents them from maximizing profits, which is their ultimate responsibility. "If all companies in the U.S. were forced to operate according to some arbitrary social agenda, rather than for profit, all American companies would operate at a disadvantage to their foreign competitors, all Americans would become less well off (some laid off), and charitable giving would decline precipitously," Rodgers said in a letter responding to the nun.

Yet on the whole, the momentum today is still with environmentalists.

Dennis Welch, American Electric's executive vice president of environment, health and safety, says if the company doesn't focus on going greener, "we're not going to survive."

American Electric's future plans include using a technology called integrated gasification combined cycle, to build coal-fueled power plants that emit less carbon dioxide. It's also investing in wind power and carbon-offsetting programs.

Still, Welch notes that sometimes green options aren't the least-cost options and for utilities, passing costs on to consumers via rate hikes is a politically daunting task. American Electric has seen costs go up, for instance, while doing work in its tree-planting program, under which it has planted 63 million trees since the late 1990s.

Lately, land prices have surged, Welch says, due to increasing demand for space to plant a particular crop. The vegetable in question? Corn for ethanol.

INVESTOR CENTER

MARKETS:
Chart
TODAY
Portfolio Chart

RESEARCH STOCKS & FUNDS

Subscriber Tool

Stock Screener

Screen over 7,000 stocks using more than 100 different variables.

Portfolio Tracker

Track your own buys and sells

See More Tools

Answer Engine
Find Answers to Life's Challenges  

Find solutions to this and many other problems using

Answer Engine from SmartMoney. 

Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit
www.djreprints.com.