Monday November 23, 2009 4:33 AM ET
SmartMoney
Published January 15, 2008  |  A A A
SmartMoney Magazine by Stephanie AuWerter (Author Archive)

Skip the DRIPs

(Page all of 2)

QUESTION: My parents have lived in their home for 18 months, have done many home improvements and want to sell as soon as possible. Is there a way around a capital-gains hit?
— Theresa Komitas, DeKalb, Ill.
For more SmartMoney Magazine features, turn to the latest issue.

ANSWER: That depends on why your parents are looking to move. While IRS rules state that homeowners who have not lived in their home for two of the past five years are subject to tax on their gains, you could drive a truck through the loopholes. If your parents are selling for health reasons, a job that's more than 50 miles away, or "unforeseen circumstances," they may be able to get a prorated exclusion on their tax bill. Unforeseen circumstances include divorce, having twins and losing one's job. If your parents have an unusual reason, they could seek a private letter ruling from the IRS, says principal tax analyst Mark Luscombe, of CCH, a tax-information publisher. (Reasons such as noisy neighbors have qualified.)

Of course, falling housing prices combined with home improvements, which increase the home's cost basis, thereby reducing the profit and, consequently, the tax on the sale, may mean there's no gain to shelter. Or the sluggish housing market may force your parents to limp over the two-year mark, in which case they can shield up to $500,000 in profit from capital gains taxes. Sadly, the days of the quick flip are over.

QUESTION: What is your take on dividend reinvestment plans (DRIPs)? I haven't heard much about them.
— Thomas Nguyen, Orlando

ANSWER: DRIPs allow investors to buy stock from a company directly, without a broker. You can get started with just a single share, and your dividends will be automatically reinvested to purchase more shares. The better plans also allow you to buy more shares outright, often with as little as $25. More than 1,200 companies, including Microsoft, Exxon Mobil and Caterpillar, offer these programs. (For a list, visit directinvesting.com.)

But what was once a good idea is now verging on obsolete: DRIPs made sense when broker commissions were high and therefore worth avoiding. Now you can buy 100 shares of Exxon for a $10 trade at most online brokerages — and have the dividends reinvested automatically at no extra charge. As a result, DRIPs are a headache at best, costly at worst. Some plans will charge for purchasing shares, and nearly all will hit you up when you're selling shares. And sell orders can take a while: You may need to send the request by mail or fax and then wait a few days for the order to be executed. "I'd rather see people collect mutual funds," says financial planner Sheryl Garrett, of Shawnee Mission, Kan. Investing directly through a fund family into a low-cost fund will give you a lot more diversification. Some fund companies, like Charles Schwab, allow investors who sign up for automatic contributions to get started in certain funds with as little as $100 a month. Bottom line? For most investors, we say skip the DRIP.

QUESTION: I recently graduated from college and started a new job. How many allowances should I claim on my W-4 to save the most on taxes?
— John Rhee, Washington, D.C.

ANSWER: It's smart to think about slashing your tax bill, but you're barking up the wrong tree. Futzing with the number of allowances you claim doesn't affect your tax hit. It simply determines how much in the way of taxes is withdrawn from your paycheck. The more allowances you claim, the less is withheld throughout the year. Each allowance basically accommodates for a tax break you anticipate on your return. So folks who have kids or own a home, for example, usually claim at least a few.

The key is to find the sweet spot. Withhold too little and you'll owe Uncle Sam a tidy sum when it comes time to file. (Really get this wrong and you could owe a penalty.) If too much is withheld — meaning you get a fat refund when you file — then you've just given the IRS an interest-free loan for the past year, says tax expert Barbara Weltman, of J.K. Lasser. Happily, your W-4 form has a worksheet on it that should get you in the ballpark.


Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
Posted by: OnlineBrokerReview
Traditional DRIPs (buying directly from the underlying company) are OK but you can basically do DRIP investing through most brokerage accounts, such as Fidelity. You can't buy new shares for free but your dividends will be reinvested in new shares without charge and most brokers will also create partial shares.

For more details and a list of brokers that support DRIPs, check out this article: http://onlinebrokerreview.blogspot.com/2009/10/dividend-reinvestment-plans-drips.html
Posted by: Genghis3
Your answer to the question about DRIPs was way off base! You say that they made sense when brokerage commissions were high and then cite the example of buying 100 shares of Exxon for a $10 trade. When did $10 become less than ZERO?? Even worse, you seem to be missing the point entirely. DRIPs are ideal for someone that has $25, $50, or $100 to invest. Buying 100 shares of XOM would cost $9-10,000 and represent a LARGE commitment to one stock. For teh same cost, a person could invest in 10, 20, or more companies, and do so on a regular (dollar-cost averaging) or irregular basis. Instead, you advise people to invest blindly in mutual funds...and forget about thinking for themselves.
Bob917

11 Comments
Some of my most sucessful investments were made using DRIPS...Many DRIPS can be started even if you don't own any shares when you start.....BUT you do have to watch for fees....on the other hand, many DRIPS have no fees and in some cases issue the stock at a discount For the little guy you has small dollar amounts to invest, DRIPS are the way to go.
As far as mutual funds, I wish they gave me half the return that I get doing my own stock investing.....For all their fees and their poor returns, they are a loser. Further they all have the 'herd' mentality....Rememer 'Buy Internet stocks'?
violino

4 Comments
My discount broker (Scottrade) does NOT re-invest dividends-that's how they keep their costs low. DRIPS are nice-I once had three. If I were investing in dividend-paying stocks now, I'd sure do it that way.
Posted by: wsplitts
DRIP investing is outmoded at best. The records keeping and IRS reporting are onerous and time consuming. I started with DRIPs when brokerage fees were high. I spent untold hours maintaining records and working on my income tax returns just to report many simple small transactions. Today's low-fee brokerages are a god-send and the transaction is made when I want to buy or sell. The article is right on point.
Advertisements
EMAIL US
Email us at ask@smartmoney.com.
(We aren't able to respond to all the emails we receive, but we'll contact you if we choose to publish your letter.)