Tuesday November 24, 2009 2:16 PM ET
SmartMoney
Published April 4, 2007  |  A A A
Real Estate by Colleen DeBaise (Author Archive)

Why Buying a Home Is the Best Option

A GOOD CHUNK OF the U.S. population refuses to give up renting. We're not sure how many renters are stubborn hold-outs (the U.S. census doesn't measure in terms of obstinacy, although we do know that the majority of Americans — about 69% — own their own home). For many, the American Dream is simply out of reach for financial reasons.

But, for others, it's not the money, it's the....well, we've come up with five reasons why people don't want to buy real estate. Perhaps you've used these excuses yourself — or know a colleague, a family member or a friend who has. We've enlisted the aid of experts — Stacy Francis and Nancy Flint-Budde, certified financial planners in New York City and Salem, N.Y., respectively, and Mark Schussel, a spokesman for Chubb Group Of Insurance Companies in Warren, N.J. — to counter these excuses and knock some sense into the real-estate challenged.


Count this as the "protest" renter — the person who perpetually rents, who thinks they're too cool for school and doesn't want to be one of those people who talks about renovation projects at a cocktail party. (The true "protest" renter also protests cocktail parties.) These people might also fear growing up, becoming their parents, owning guest towels, etc.

Counter: Well, owning your own home IS a responsibility — and if you're not ready for it, then don't do it. Of course, you'll miss out on nice tax breaks for mortgage interest and property taxes, which make owning a compelling proposition for many. Not to mention, you're not exactly building equity when you split the rent with the roomies (but, hey, it does help with the cable bill).

"I look at renting as writing a check and throwing it out in the garbage," says Francis, who often advises clients on buying apartments in Manhattan. For many people, buying a home is their first crack at building their net worth over the long term, she says. The traditional way to ease into home ownership is to buy something like a condominium or townhouse, so your weekends aren't spent at the home-improvement store picking up weedwhackers. But be careful: You might feel like a real adult once you own. "You are no longer at the whims of your landlord to raise your rent, or sell your building," Francis says. "It really gives you stability."


Truth be told, there is some logic to that. After all, if something breaks in your rental apartment, you just call your landlord. You don't spend money on pricey renovations. Heck, you don't have to pay property taxes. And if you've got enough money for a down payment, why dump that cash into an expensive home, when you could use it to buy something like stocks instead?

Counter: Many people consider their home an investment. "We call it a 'use asset,'" says Flint-Budde. "It's an asset that you own, and you hope it will appreciate, but you are using it along the way." That means even if your home doesn't appreciate as much as your favorite stock or exchange-trade fund, you still gain because it doubles (hopefully) as a nice place to live. And homes historically appreciate over time — so if you are able to hold onto your abode for a minimum of five years, you'll likely see a significant increase in value, Flint-Budde says. In its latest report, the National Association of Realtors said typical sellers are still experiencing healthy gains on the value of their home over the last five years, even in areas where prices have fallen. The group estimates that the median five-year price gain is 41.8%.

Still rather build your securities portfolio than buy a house? "If you have to turn around and pay $1,000 a month to rent somewhere, you may have less available to put into stocks," Flint-Budde points out. "And at the end of the day, if you put some into stocks and some into real estate, you would have diversified your portfolio more."

Oh, and for those averse to paying taxes? Don't fool yourself. Even renters pay property taxes. That's often what most of your rent check goes to pay, and your landlord — not you — gets the tax deduction.

SmartMoney.com would like to invite you to visit our Variable Annuities Custom Resource Center.
Click here to find out more about this financial product and how it may apply to you.

1
2
Next

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS ETrade
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
Posted by: hi_there
it is now 3/18/2008.
BSC crashed, yesterday to $2.
FED has cut rates today, again by 75 basis points.
Long term mortgage interest rates still going up.
Mortgage paper (securities) so risky, nobody wants to buy them.
Recession around the corner.
housing prices declined 8.9% average across the US in 2007
expected, another 15% decline
Yes, go buy a house
It will give you some more stress during the recession.
Renting is cheaper and thats what the smart money is doing
good luck
Posted by: jshreeves7
droelhaf, $1,000 in rent won't buy you the same house that you could have if you were paying $2,000 in mortgage. Plus you'll get back a third of that $2,000 back in tax savings. I rent and pay about the same as you, the only difference is my company will probably relocate me within the next 4 months. If you're staying in that town for a while, BUY! Otherwise write cards to money$mart asking him how the good life is. - Jamie Shreeves
Posted by: money$mart
As a landlord, I would like to thank you and everyone out there with this mentality for helping to fund my retirement. I will think of you fondly when I am basking in the sun on a white, sandy beach in the Carribean enjoying my early, and quite comfortable, retirement.
Posted by: droelhaf
The problem is, I could pay $2000 a month in mortgage payments plus $4000 a year in property taxes or pay the $1000 in rent I am paying. Somehow buying a house right now just doesn't add up.
BackType
Comments From Around the Web
Posted by: haroldeavent on Twitter

Why Buying A Home Is The Best Option http://ow.ly/tVDs

Advertisements