Monday November 23, 2009 1:17 AM ET
SmartMoney
Published July 27, 2009  |  A A A
Consumer Action by Lisa Scherzer (Author Archive)

Is the U.S. Becoming More Like Europe?

1
2
3
4
5
Next
 

Six months into the Obama presidency, the administration's legislative goals have begun to crystallize, and many have spurred debate. Among the themes that are emerging is a storyline championed by conservative commentators that the president's initiatives bear a distinct resemblance to European policies. Some have gone as far as to invoke the word, "socialist."

Politics aside, there is much to be gained by examining the successes and failures of real-world models of American policy goals. To assess the viability of those goals and the similarities between White House plans for legislation and Europe's policies, SmartMoney analyzed four of the president's recent initiatives and compared them to analogous policies in Europe.

For example, the president says he intends to remake the nation's health-care system. Congress is wrangling over the details of how to pay for the massive overhaul, and Obama took his plan to the public in a prime time news conference this week. The fundamental idea behind the plan – to expand coverage to the more than 40 million Americans who have no insurance – parallels health care systems in other countries, most notably in Western Europe.

Obama has also called for the development of a high-speed rail system and a cap and trade system to limit carbon emissions – each has a counterpart in Europe. And the cash for clunkers program that went into effect last week followed a similar program launched in Germany.

"There's a lot going on all over the world. The U.S. is trying to figure out what would work best given its unique situation," says Mark Browne, a professor of risk management at the Wisconsin School of Business. "It's certainly in our best interest to keep track of what's going on in other places."

SmartMoney.com would like to invite you to visit our Variable Annuities Custom Resource Center.
Click here to find out more about this financial product and how it may apply to you.

1
2
3
4
5
Next
 

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
Posted by: jwwhi
The problem with the whole debate about reforming our health care system is not so much about the details as it is about the whole premise. Do we really want a reform of our health care system performed by the government?
The government is responsible for most of the problems with our healthcare system. The massive number of illegal aliens driving up costs to providers, insurers required to provide types of coverage on all policies whether that coverage is desired or not, government mandates, ridiculous payments by medicare/medicaid so that doctors have to charge more to insurers and self-pay patients in order to make up the losses.

The other fallacy of the government debates is in regard to whether or not it should have the authority to mandate participation. This used to be a free country, theoretically. Individuals supposedly have the right to spend their money on purchases they desire. Is this country of the people or of the government? Are our rights inaliena...(Read more of this comment)
Posted by: jwwhi
The problem with the whole debate about reforming our health care system is not so much about the details as it is about the whole premise. Do we really want a reform of our health care system performed by the government.
The government is responsible for most of the problems with our healthcare system. The massive number of illegal aliens driving up costs to providers, insurers required to provide types of coverage on all policies whether that coverage is desired or not, government mandates, rediculous payments by medicare/medicaid so that doctors have to charge more to insurers and self-pay patients in order to make up the losses.

The other fallacy of the government debates is in regard to whether or not it should have the authority to mandate participation. This used to be a free country, theoretically. Individuals supposedly have the right to spend their money on purchases they desire. Is this country of the people or of the government? Are our rights inaliena...(Read more of this comment)
Posted by: jordanconor
Also, you don't have to go "that far" to invoke the word socialism if you understand that it's a derivative of statism, the general idea being that the state has more ability to make decisions for individuals without their consent. So what I say to the statists at this point is "please get your hand out of my pocket, I'm perfectly capable of making decisions without your assistance".
Posted by: jordanconor
Sorry Lisa, I called you Linda, I apologize.
Posted by: jordanconor
Linda Scherzer:

Do you understand that the "more than 40 million" people who don't have health care statement is misleading propaganda? When you include even one bit of misleading propaganda in your articles that means I have to discount everything else you say. Just so you understand that your credibility flies out the window.
Advertisements

Related Quotes

NWS 14.13 Down -0.59 -4.01%