Which IRA Is Best? (Retirement: Personal Finance) at SmartMoney.com

Which IRA Is Best?

Active Discussions on SmartMoney

	Which IRA Is Best?
	Savable Worksheets Now Available on SmartMoney Select Your browser is not Java-enabled. To view our interactive tools properly, you need to be using a Java-enabled browser (Microsoft Internet Explorer v. 3 or above, or Netscape v. 3 or above), preferably on a Windows 95 and higher machine. If this configuration matches yours, check to make sure Java and Javascript are enabled in your browser options. If the configuration described is not available, please download and install the Java plug-in. Click on icon below to install Java plug-in. Internet Explorer 5.x & 6.x: Select Tools from your menu bar Select Internet Options, then the Security tab. Make sure the Internet icon is selected amongst the Web content zones. Select Custom Level... for the Security level. Scroll down to the Java area of the list. Make sure that, under Java permissions, that 'Disable Java' is NOT active. Set this to low, medium, or high security instead. Scroll down to the Scripting area of the list. Under Scripting, set Active scripting to Enable, and set Scripting of Java applets to Enable. Click OK to return the Security Settings, then click Apply, and then OK. Internet Explorer 4.x: Select View from your menu bar Select Internet Options, then the Security tab. For the Internet Zone, select Custom and click on Settings. Scroll down to the Java area of the list. Make sure that, under Java permissions, that 'Disable Java' is NOT active. Set this to low, medium, or high security instead. Scroll down to the Scripting area of the list. Under Scripting, set Active scripting to Enable, and set Scripting of Java applets to Enable. Click OK to return the Security Settings, then click Apply, and then OK. Internet Explorer 3.x: Select View from your menu bar Select Options, then select the Security tab. At the bottom of the page in the Active Content box, make sure all boxes are checked. (Note: You might also want to click the Safety Level button here and select Medium to prevent warning message interruptions.) Netscape 4.x, 5.x, & 6.x: Select Edit from your menu bar Select Preferences, then select Advanced. "Enable Java" and "Enable Java script" should both be checked. Click OK. Netscape 3.0: Select Options from your menu bar Select Network Preferences, then select LANGUAGES. "Enable Java" and "Enable Javascript" should both be checked. Click OK. This calculator will figure the after-tax value of your investments in different IRA accounts at age 59 1/2, assuming you make the maximum annual contributions until then (including catch-up contributions once you reach 50). For the tax-deductible IRA, we assume you invest your tax savings each year and earn the same return as on your IRA. However, we tax those returns annually as income.

	In This Section
	Roth IRAs: You Wanted to Know Estate Planning With a Roth IRA Worksheets Roth IRAs: To Convert or Not Which IRA Is Best? More...

Send

Buzz up this story
on Yahoo!

Listen to this site on my phone with Jott Feeds

Updated on January 9, 2008.

WITH THREE FLAVORS to choose from — Roth, deductible or nondeductible — figuring out which IRA is best for you can be confusing. But everybody who plans to retire ought to have at least one of them. Outside of your corporate retirement plan, an IRA is the best way for you to accumulate tax-advantaged retirement savings.

Our favorite IRA is the Roth. Unlike traditional IRAs (both tax-deductible and nondeductible), withdrawals from Roth IRAs after age 59 1/2 are generally not taxed. You pay your taxes on the front end by contributing after-tax dollars. So Roth IRAs enable savers who remain in the same income tax bracket (or higher) at retirement to accumulate more money than even tax-deductible IRAs do. To see how your investment would fare in each type of IRA account, use our applet to the right.

Besides fostering tax-free growth, the Roth IRA has flexible withdrawal rules. You can take out contributions (but not gains) for any reason without penalty or taxes. And after you reach age 59 1/2 and have had the account open for five years, you can withdraw your gains tax- and penalty-free as well. Ditto, if you become disabled.

Trouble is, everyone isn't eligible to open a Roth IRA. Who qualifies for 2008? Joint filers with modified adjusted gross income, or MAGI, below $169,000, and individuals with MAGI below $116,000. (Though eligible contributions start to phase out at $159,000 for joint filers and $101,000 for individuals.)

Like traditional IRAs, the Roth IRA allows 2008 contributions of $5,000 per person ($6,000 if you are age 50 or older at the end of the year). But taxpayers with MAGIs under $100,000 (married or single) can also roll over assets from their traditional IRA accounts into a Roth. You'll pay income tax on the rollover, but not on withdrawals, which would then be governed by the more liberal Roth IRA rules. (See "Roth IRAs: To Convert or Not.")

For a rundown on the rules for contributions and withdrawals for all IRAs, see our "IRA Primer." And remember, if your employer matches your 401(k) contributions, you should contribute up to the matching limit before establishing an IRA.

So, unless you expect to be in a much lower tax bracket during retirement than you are now, a Roth IRA is a better deal than even a tax-deductible IRA. And it's always a better deal than a nondeductible one.

The IRA Buffet

Tax-deductible IRA
Who's Eligible	In tax-year 2008, eligibility phases out for individuals with MAGI between $53,000 and $63,000 and for married couples with MAGI between $85,000 and $105,000. No income cap for singles not covered by an employer-sponsored retirement plan or for married couples when neither participates in such a plan. If only one spouse participates in an employer-sponsored plan, deductible IRA eligibility for 2008 phases out between MAGI of $159,000 and $169,000 for uncovered spouse, between $85,000 and $105,000 for covered spouse.
Annual Contribution	$5,000 tax-deductible ($6,000 if you are age 50 or older at year-end).
Withdrawals	Withdrawals taxed as income. Penalty-free withdrawals permitted before age 59 1/2 for first-time home purchase up to $10,000, higher education expenses or in event of disability or death.

Roth IRA
Who's Eligible	For 2008, eligibility phases out between MAGI of $101,000 and $116,000 for singles, and $159,000 and $169,000 for married couples.
Annual Contribution	$5,000 not tax-deductible ($6,000 if you are age 50 or older at year-end).
Withdrawals	Tax-free and penalty-free withdrawals of earnings plus contributions after five years if you are 59 1/2 or in the following circumstances: death, disability or for first-time home purchase up to $10,000. Penalty-free, but not tax-free withdrawals permitted before age 59 1/2 for higher education expenses.

Nondeductible IRA
Who's Eligible	Everyone who has earned income.
Annual Contribution	For 2008, $5,000 ($6,000 if you are age 50 or older at year-end).
Withdrawals	Withdrawals of earnings taxed as income. Penalty-free withdrawals permitted before age 59 1/2 for first-time home purchase up to $10,000, higher education expenses or in event of disability or death.

Last comment on this story

	CashedOut	Posted: 8:50 PM On September 23, 2008

Can someone please tell me If Rolling over my 401k in an IRA account with Met Life a good Idea? Are they FDIC insured? Thank you in advance.

Read/Post Comments(1)

To license this content, click here