A Green Christmas: What You'll Really Pay

Eco-minded families may be dreaming of a green Christmas, but they'll pay a premium to make that dream a reality amid the recession this holiday season.

The options are diverse everything from energy-efficient LED Christmas lights to organic candy canes. But how much more does an environmentally-friendly Christmas cost? SmartMoney.com went holiday shopping to find out. After comparing prices, we discovered that it s not easy or cheap being green.

Order 100 holiday cards printed on recycled paper from TinyPrints and it will cost $137 $8, or an extra 6%, more than the exact same cards printed on regular paper stock. A dozen organic candy canes? That ll be an added $1.11, or 38%. Buy Junior a PlanToys wooden train set made with recycled Rubberwood and water-based paints and spend an extra $15, or 27%, compared with the Fisher-Price plastic Geotrax set.

Then there s the biggest budget buster: energy-efficient holiday lights. At Christmaslights.com, a 24-foot string of 70 LED mini-lights costs $17.98, nearly $13 more than a string of 100 incandescent mini-lights. Buy around 400 lights for a six-foot tree, and you could end up spending an extra $87.80. Looking on the bright side, LED lights claim to be up to 90% more energy efficient than conventional holiday bulbs, which could translate into a monthly savings of $4 a month on your energy bill if you light your tree for 10 hours a day, according to the EnergyIdeas Clearinghouse, which is managed by Washington State University Extension Energy Program.

One environmentally-friendly purchase that won't cost more is a live Christmas tree that can be replanted in your yard or in a local park. The potted tree we found at Simonson Farms in Cranbury, N.J., cost $50, the same amount as a cut tree. (While you won t find a tree with its roots at every corner tree lot, many tree farms do carry them.)

We didn't even delve into how much an organic holiday meal will run. Read our story here

The premiums we found at online retailers for eco-friendly products are fairly typical, according to Bob Schildgen, a founding director of the Green Chamber of Commerce, a lobbying and business organization that promotes environmental practices. It can cost anywhere from 10% to 40% more for any item that s produced through a more environmentally-sound process, he says.

View our slideshow to see how much more you'd have to pay for a Green Christmas:

[Christmas Trees]

Green Alternative

Potted, live Christmas tree

$50
Non-Green Alternative

Fresh-Cut Christmas Tree

$50

Price Difference

0%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
0%

A potted, live tree won t cost you extra, but keeping it alive until you re ready to plant it could prove challenging.

Source: Simonson Farms

[Holiday Cards]

Green Alternative

Recycled paper holiday cards

$137
Non-Green Alternative

Traditional holiday cards

$129

Price Difference

6%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$187 / 4%

The recycled prints cost just 6% more than cards on regular paper stock. However, if you really want to protect the environment and save money send a card via email.

Source: TinyPrints.com

[TV]

Green Alternative

Philips 42-inch LCD Eco TV for Dad

$1,170 (with shipping)
Non-Green Alternative

Toshiba 42-inch LCD TV

$1,100 (free shipping)

Price Difference

6%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$1,357 / 6%

Philips energy-efficient flat-screen TV is a bit pricier than a similar-sized Toshiba set, but over time, a household that watches a lot of television could save on their electricity bill.

Source: Philips Electronics/Buy.com
Photo courtesy of Philips Electronics

[TV]

Green Alternative

Organic Fruit Cake

$25
Non-Green Alternative

Fruit Cake

$20

Price Difference

25%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$1,382 / 6%

Your health-conscious guests will appreciate the effort made to find an organic fruit cake, but the premium may not be worth it if no one bothers to eat it.

Source: Old Cavendish Products

[Wooden train set for a son]

Green Alternative

Wooden train set for a son

$69.99
Non-Green Alternative

Fisher-Price train set

$54.49

Price Difference

27%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$1,452 / 7%

PlanToys train set is made from organic Rubberwood and water-based inks, but it lacks the bells and whistles featured on the Fischer-Price Geotrax set.

Source: PlanToys/Amazon.com
Photo courtesy of PlanToys

[Soy-inked, recycled wrapping paper]

Green Alternative

Vegetable-based-ink recycled wrapping paper

$6.95
Non-Green Alternative

Traditional wrapping paper

$5.34

Price Difference

30%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$1,459 / 7%

While the eco-friendly wrapping paper may look nice, few people use enough of the stuff in any given year to stop global warming.

Note: The price for Papyrus traditional wrapping paper is based on a 10-foot roll priced at $8.95.

Source: Peacefulvalleygreetings.com, Papyrus

[Organic Candy Canes]

Green Alternative

Organic Candy Canes

$3.99
Non-Green Alternative

Traditional Candy Canes

$2.88

Price Difference

38%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$1,463 / 7%

As pure a candy cane as you ll find, but our environmental experts had a good chuckle when we asked if we could save the planet by buying these candies.

Source: Pure Fun/Amazon.com
Photo courtesy of Pure Fun

[Organic Cotton Layette Set]

Green Alternative

Organic Cotton Layette Set

$45.00
Non-Green Alternative

Cotton Layette Set

$29.50

Price Difference

52%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$1,508 / 8%

Far fewer pesticides are used to produce organic cotton, but this adorable layette set seems a bit pricy considering a baby will grow out of in no time.

Source: Teacollection.com

[Eco-friendly cultured pearl pendant for Mom]

Green Alternative

Eco-friendly cultured pearl pendant for Mom

$500
Non-Green Alternative

Traditional cultured pearl pendant

$89

Price Difference

73%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$2,008 / 19%

This necklace is from a pearl farm that pays special attention to preservation and environmental responsibility. An even greener choice: Buy a piece of estate jewelry.

Source: Brilliantearth.com/Buy.com
Photo courtesy of Brilliantearth.com

[Energy-efficient LED lights]

Green Alternative

Energy-efficient LED lights

$107.88
Non-Green Alternative

Incandescent lights

$20

Price Difference

440%
Green Christmas Total and % Premium
$2,116 / 24%

LED lights could save you a few dollars on your holiday energy bill, but it s a lot to spend if you already own incandescent lights.

Source: Christmaslights.com

Note: Prices are for 420 LED mini-lights (six boxes) and 400 (four boxes) traditional mini-lights.

INVESTOR CENTER

MARKETS:
Chart
TODAY
Portfolio Chart

RESEARCH STOCKS & FUNDS

  • How to Pay for a Wedding

    With most couples waiting to marry and three quarters of marriage partners living together first, many celebrants are paying at least part of their wedding bill.

  • How to Teach Kids about Money

    It’s never too early to start talking dollars...and sense.

  • How to Manage Your Grocery Bill

    Your grocery bill is your biggest weekly household expense, so keeping a lid on it will go far to stretch your dollar.

Answer Engine
Find Answers to Life's Challenges  

Find solutions to this and many other problems using

Answer Engine from SmartMoney. 

Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit
www.djreprints.com.