Ditching Your Cellphone Provider on the Cheap

FOR WIRELESS CUSTOMERS, the price of freedom has long come in the form of exorbitant early termination charges. A customer who abandoned a contract before it was set to expire could expect to pay as much as $200. And for a family of four looking to ditch their wireless plan, fees could climb to an astronomical $800.

But now, customers are fighting back and claiming some sizable wins. Last month, a California court ruled that Sprint's early termination fees were illegal because they were, as the court decision said, "implemented primarily as a means to discourage customers from leaving" their contracts. Sprint was ordered to pay $73 million in damages. And Verizon Wireless recently agreed to pay $21 million to settle a lawsuit filed by subscribers in California that alleged its early termination fees were excessive and violated state law.

The activism seems to be working. "I think carriers are finally waking up. They don't want to tick off the customer," says Jeff Kagan, a telecom industry analyst. Now, instead of charging a flat fee no matter what, carriers are prorating penalties, which decrease as customers get further along in their contract. Moving to a prorated fee structure is "something they're all going do," Kagan says, "and I think you'll see them do it fairly quickly."

The new cost of breaking up

With the exception of Sprint, all the major carriers have made their early termination fees more subscriber-friendly. (According to a company spokeswoman, Sprint plans to institute a new prorated fee schedule by the end of the year.) Here are their new prorated plans:

Wireless Carrier

Previous early termination fee

Current early termination fee

Who's eligible for prorated fees?

Verizon Wireless

Flat $175

Starts at $175 at the beginning of the contract. For each month that a customer sticks to their contract, the fee is reduced by $5. In effect since November 2006.

New subscribers and those renewing contracts after November 2006.

Sprint

N/A

$200 flat fee (The company plans to introduce a prorated structure by end of 2008.)

N/A

T-Mobile

Flat $200

$200 with more than 180 days remaining on contract; $100 with 91-180 days left; $50 with 31-91 days remaining; either $50 or the standard monthly charge, whichever is less, for those with fewer than 30 days remaining. In effect since June 2008.

New subscribers and those renewing contracts after June 30, 2008.

AT&T

Flat $175

Starts at $175 at the beginning of the contract. For each month that a customer sticks to their contract, the fee is reduced by $5. In effect since May 2008.

New subscribers and those renewing contracts after May 25, 2008.

Ensuring an Amicable Split

To help reduce your chances of going through a contentious divorce with your carrier, follow these steps:

Take a test drive

Take advantage of the free trials most carriers offer, suggests Jeff Blyskal, senior editor at Consumer Reports. "Check out the service, use it where you'd be traveling to or in your home," he says. If you're unhappy for whatever reason, return the phone, get a refund for the handset and activation fee, and try another service.

Seek flexibility

Worried you won't be able to stick to a long-term relationship with your carrier? If that's the case, look for the shortest contract possible, says Blyskal. That way, if you're dissatisfied with the service, you won't be locked in for too long. Verizon, for example, offers a one-year contract. Just be aware that discounts on phones vary depending on the type of plan. "You'll pay a little more for the phone, but you'll have your freedom at least," says Blyskal.

If even a year seems like too much of a commitment, consider a prepaid plan. In most cases, you'll have to pay full price for the phone, but having the freedom to leave at will, without paying a penalty, can make it worthwhile.

Here are prepaid and pay-as-you-go wireless plans that are currently available:

Carrier

Monthly/
daily cost

Minutes

Cost per
minute

AT&T GoPhone prepaid plan

$29.99 - $69.99

200-650 (Except for the $29.99 plan, all offer at least 500 night and weekend minutes as well.)

15 cents or less

Sprint Boost Mobile prepaid plan

$50-$70

Unlimited local and nationwide calling from your home-calling area

15 cents per minute outside home area

T-Mobile Pay by the Day prepaid plan

$1 per day on days you use your phone

Unlimited nights and in-network calling

10 cents per minute on all other domestic calls

Verizon Wireless "Core" Pay As You Go plan

99 cents per day on days you use your phone

Unlimited in-network calling

10 cents per minute for night and weekend calls

Look for legal loopholes

Almost all of the major carriers have a "material adverse change" clause. Under this clause, if a carrier changes the terms of a contract, say by raising the text messaging rate, it must provide notice to subscribers and give them at least 14 days to bail out without worrying about paying an early termination fee. "That opens a small window of time to fight the company to get out of the contract legally," says Joe Ridout, spokesman for Consumer Action, a consumer advocacy group. Make sure to read any notices you receive from your carrier carefully, he says. If you continue to use your service beyond the "get out" date, it's an indication that you accept their changes.

If your rates have been raised and the company refuses to waive the early termination fee, filing an official complaint with the FCC and your public utilities commission "will maximize your chance of success because phone companies don't like to get in trouble," says Ridout.

Also See:
Third-Party Service Fees Sneaking Onto Wireless Bills
7 Nasty Airline Fees and How to Avoid Them
Switching Carriers to Get the iPhone Can Cost You

INVESTOR CENTER

MARKETS:
Chart
TODAY
Portfolio Chart

RESEARCH STOCKS & FUNDS

Answer Engine
Find Answers to Life's Challenges  

Find solutions to this and many other problems using

Answer Engine from SmartMoney. 

Copyright 2012 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved
This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints at 1-800-843-0008 or visit
www.djreprints.com.