Sunday November 22, 2009 6:33 PM ET
SmartMoney
Published October 22, 2007  |  A A A
Deal of the Day by Kelli B. Grant (Author Archive)

Budgeting Software: A Free Way to Manage Your Finances

Updated on December 31, 2007.

IT'S HARD TO miss the irony: Some of the most popular software designed to help people take control of their day-to-day spending can end up being real budget busters.

Microsoft Money or Intuit's Quicken, for example, start at $20 and $30, respectively. On top of that, users often have to pay their bank a bunch of extra fees (ostensibly the fees are for allowing these programs regular access to your daily financial transactions). Bank of America, for example, charges $9.95 a month in most states, while Wells Fargo tacks on $3 — plus $6.95 if you use the third-party software for online bill pay.

All of a sudden using a pen and paper to balance your checkbook sounds a lot more enticing, right? But for those who just want the budgeting basics, there are some online personal-finance programs worth considering. Even better, most of these programs are free. Sure, these web sites may not offer advanced features — like managing your investments and tracking financial goals as Money and Quicken do — but they can be an especially useful tool when it comes to juggling the household finances.

"The big advantage is that you can see and manage all your accounts from one place, which in turn helps you figure out where you want to go, financially," says Gerri Detweiler, a credit advisor for Credit.com and author of "The Ultimate Credit Handbook."

Here's how these online programs work: You set up the site so it has the necessary login information to access all of your accounts. That way, the program can download transactions such as your latest credit-card purchase or the amount you deposited at the ATM. You can then group these transactions together to see, for example, what percentage of your income is spent on groceries and what percentage is spent on clothing.

Before signing onto one of these sites though, you should know that not all of them are created equal. Here's what to look for when choosing your virtual personal finance manager.

Phishing, data-stealing viruses, hackers — thinking about all of the potential security breaches that can occur online can be overwhelming. "You have to ask yourself, 'How comfortable am I providing one web site with all of my account numbers and passwords?'" says Ed Kountz, a senior analyst for financial services at Jupiter Research.

However, experts agree that the threat of your data being compromised through a breach of the site itself is minimal. "The real risk here is on the end user" — meaning you, says Ron Teixeira, president of the National Cyber Security Alliance. "If someone gets into your computer and steals that one password for the site, they have access to all your data," he says. "It's the mother lode." To protect yourself, install and update firewalls, antivirus software and antispyware programs frequently. Also, regularly change your passwords for both the budget program and your bank accounts, taking care to use a complex combination of letters, numbers and other characters.

But even good security on your end is no reason to be lax about which budget program you pick, says Kountz. "As these sites gain traction, they will become targets," he predicts. "Fraudsters go where the pickins are, so to speak."

To choose wisely, search blogs and personal review sites like Epinions.com to see what other users are saying about a particular finance site. Also, look for security seals from companies like HackerSafe, VeriSign and Thawte. These icons verify that certain security measures are in place to protect your information. Once you've narrowed your options, read the site's privacy and security policies carefully to see how your information is protected, and under what circumstances (if any) it will be shared.

The best personal-finance manager sites have three features in common, says Detweiler:
Account compatibility. "The advantage of these programs is that you can see all your accounts in one place," says Detweiler. That said, some sites have difficulty culling transactions from small, independent banks or those that use an extra layer of security or encryption, such as asking you to confirm a picture upon login. Check that a site works with all your accounts before becoming too invested. One caveat: It's rare for these free programs to access data from investment houses or student-loan providers.
Transaction alerts. Falling off the wagon when it comes to your financial diet is all too easy. So look for a program that offers you notification that, say, a credit-card bill is due soon or that your checking account balance is dangerously close to zero. Such alerts also double as instant notification of irregular activity, which could help protect you against fraud and identity theft, says Teixeira.
Customization. While you shouldn't have to manually type in or tweak every transaction, your program should offer some leeway to identify and organize certain purchases into set categories, says Detweiler. (For example, instructing the site to recognize the name of your favorite independent boutique as a clothing purchase.) Without this option, you may find your purchases tilting heavily toward "miscellaneous," which won't help you identify areas where you need to cut back.

Here's what a few of these free programs offer:

Online Personal-Finance Manager Features
 Clear CheckbookMintWesabeYodlee Money Center
Downloads data directly from your accountsYesYesYesYes
Allows you to manually enter transactions (say, for cash purchases)YesNoYesYes
Tracks checking, savings and credit-card accountsYesYesYesYes
Tracks brokerage accountsYesNoYesYes
Sets monthly spending limitsYesNoYesYes
Customizes transactionsYesYesYesYes
Category-based spending history and breakdownYesYesYesYes
Merchant-based spending history and breakdownNoYesYesNo
Text-message alertsNoYesNoNo
Email alertsYesYesNoYes
Allows you to manage accounts via cellphoneYesNoNoNo
* Data from individual sites.

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
seletit

1 Comments
IMHO, personal finances should be managed in some 'personal' space, like your personal computer. You can go online to the bank or credit card company website (you personally, not some remote computer) to download your transactions, but still manage all your transactions in your personal space.
In our journey to manage our finances, we created Simple Home Budget ( http://www.home-budget-software.com ), to manage all our finances in one place, at home, on our computer, without required internet access. We don't download transactions (also Simple Home Budget can import bank statement files) - we just enter them - Simple Home Budget was designed to enter all your receipts (cash, credit, debit) very fast and convenient (transactions are created in seconds and when you enter them, it's additional reminder to control your money).

Posted by: EllenWA
I have two paychecks and two checking accounts.. and one savings account.

One paycheck goes into an account with auto pay for all my monthly bills except the Power bill... and it is paid out of this account with bill payers.. as Power bill is so different depending on the time of year. I started doing this when I was ill and couldn't seem to get the bills paid.. it has been a life saver. If you have Parents that you are helping manage their lives,this is a real help for us seniors. My second account is the one I have for the extra bills, trips etc. I have a saving attached to this one and try to put someting in the savings everymonth.
Posted by: joebigsky1127
Any suggestions from readers?
Advertisements