Monday March 22, 2010 3:20 AM ET
SmartMoney
A A A
SmartMoney Magazine by Noah Rothbaum (Author Archive)

10 Things Your iPod Won't Tell You

Below is an excerpt from the book "1,001 Things They Won't Tell You," which was published in May 2009 and highlights popular columns from SmartMoney's long-running "10 Things" feature.


1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Next
 

1. “It’s good to be king—but my reign may be coming to an end.”

Since launching the iPod in 2001, Apple has been the undisputed leader in digital music players, owning 70 percent of the market. What has set the iPod apart is not only its hip, user-friendly design but also its companion iTunes music store, the first online audio megamart, offering an ever-expanding catalog of songs for purchase at the click of a mouse. This two-pronged approach has given Apple a huge lead over competitors; so far the company has sold over 120 million iPods and more than 4 billion songs on iTunes. But the iPod’s days at the top may be numbered.

At issue is Apple’s proprietary format, which up until recently has made iTunespurchased music incompatible with other non-iPod MP3 players. According to Chris Crotty, former senior analyst for consumer electronics at iSuppli, such closed systems either move toward compatibility or get surpassed by the competition. Apple has seen the writing on the wall—in January 2009, it unveiled its plan to make it easier for consumers to recode music into the more standard MP3 format. Good idea, according to the experts. “Over time the market prefers open systems,” Crotty says.

1,001 Things They Won't Tell You

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Next
 

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
Posted by: degrees_of_truth
The bits about "proprietary" format and lock-in are wrong. AAC is an international standard, more modern than MP3 and employing more efficient compression than MP3. A song encoded in AAC is higher quality for the same file size, or occupies a smaller file with the same quality. Competitors may choose to only support the older MP3 format, but it's not Apple's fault. And increasingly AAC is an option on competitor players.

It is true that Apple initially employed a digital rights management mechanism to obtain the music industry's support, which enabled the whole thing to get off the ground. But there has been no DRM on iTunes store music for quite some time now; all music is in the open-standard AAC format.

And of course, it was always possible to play MP3's on iPods.

By the way, Rob Enderle seems to make most of his living by praising Microsoft products and criticizing anything that competes.
Posted by: J Carbone
Posted by: Keldawwg
The new iPods with hard drives have Samsung drives in them, much more robust than the old Toshiba drives they put in the old 20GB and 30Gb models. They were fragile hard drives. The Mini's have either Hitachi or Seagate drives. The Hitachi's are better, but my 6GB Mini is Seagate and it's still working perfectly... Lot of spills over the years, no problem at all.
Posted by: Keldawwg
We also have 3 nano's. 1st gen died when my son's xbox 360 fell off his dresser on it. 2nd gen works perfectly, 3rd gen works perfectly... I have spare hard drives in case the Mini's die, but they are just sitting in a drawer... You can set iTunes and Windows Media Player to rip to MP3...
Posted by: Keldawwg
I have two iPod Mini's that are almost 4 years old... I had to replace the batteries, but it was easy and cheap (Bought new ones on eBay) They have hard drives, and still work perfectly. I ripped all my music (23,000+ songs) to mp3. I like iTunes! iPods just work better!
Advertisements
 
Retrieving data...