Monday November 23, 2009 1:23 PM ET
SmartMoney
Published September 7, 2007  |  A A A
SmartMoney Magazine by Shahryar Motia (Author Archive)

10 Things Campus Security Won't Tell You

Experts agree that colleges have improved campus safety over the past 20 years. Shuttle vans, escorts, call boxes and electronic ID for dorm access were once standard only at a few schools. And where unarmed night watchmen used to stroll the grounds, today many campuses employ armed security guards with police-academy training. In the post-9/11 era and in the wake of the Virginia Tech shootings, vigilance is at an all-time high, and most students say they feel safe. However, many security experts believe schools still have a way to go.

The first step: allocating more money to campus security. According to Harper College police chief Mike Alsup, colleges tend to earmark about 1.5% of their budget for security. "It's the lowest priority for funding, based on the school budgets I've seen," says S. Daniel Carter, VP of Security on Campus, a nonprofit that focuses on crime prevention and victim assistance. Colleges' primary concern is educating students, Carter explains; if money's tight, "they're going to cut the campus police officer, not the professor." Scott Jaschik, cofounder of InsideHigherEd.com, agrees: "There are no Nobel Prizes for safe campuses."

In 1986, 19-year-old Jeanne Ann Clery was raped and murdered in her dorm room at Lehigh University. In court, her parents learned that 38 violent crimes had occurred on campus in the past three years — a fact Lehigh had never disclosed. Subsequently, the Clery Act mandated that all colleges receiving federal student aid must make campus crime information available to students and employees. But two decades later, "violations of the act are widespread," Carter says; a recent Department of Justice study found that only 37% of schools report sexual-assault crimes in accordance with the act.

One major problem is schools' failing to provide "timely warning" about crimes that could threaten campus safety. A recent example: After Eastern Michigan University student Laura Dickinson was found dead in her room last December, the university said there was no reason to suspect foul play — until police later arrested a fellow student for her rape and murder. Turns out top school officials had covered up a grisly crime investigation. In July university president John Fallon was fired. (An EMU spokesperson could not comment before press time.)

Despite the Clery Act, even federally funded schools don't have to make available all crime records. Incident reports, for example, may be off limits. In general, public schools are subject to the degree of transparency that state open-records laws demand. Georgia, however, goes a step further: Anyone — not just students — can access all police reports from both private and public colleges under the state's open-records law. "Schools must provide public reports," explains Atlanta-based attorney Ben Barrett. "Policing is a public act."

Outside Georgia, private schools are another matter. In Massachusetts, for example, incident reports don't have to be open even to students. The state Supreme Court ruled as much last year, after student newspaper The Harvard Crimson sued the university police department to provide incident reports on alleged sexual assaults and other crimes. The court reasoned that because Harvard is private, it doesn't have to play by public rules. This is also why private-college crime logs are not as detailed as police logs — "they don't have to put who," according to Mike Hiestand, legal consultant for Student Press Law Center.

Living off campus appeals to college kids on many levels. It satisfies an ever-increasing desire for freedom and independence. There's a taste of "real life" responsibilities: rent, bills, commute, household chores (okay, scratch that one). It even saves parents money. But it can sometimes be all too real for young people out on their own for the first time, since living on private property not owned by the school — whether the apartment is 10 steps or 10 miles from campus — absolves the college of any security obligations. Locks, alarms, adequate lighting — all these issues have to be taken up with landlords.

For their part, most colleges do provide a cursory safety talk during orientation, but they feel there's not much else they can do to protect students who live on their own. What makes life outside the confines of campus so dangerous? Not surprisingly, the majority of off-campus incidents occur between 6 p.m. and 6 a.m., with half the victims reporting they were engaged in "leisure activity" at the time. Translation? "If you're out late at night and three sheets to the wind, you're an easy mark," says Bath, from Security on Campus.

The potential for large-scale disaster is now part of public consciousness. While schools are mindful enough to examine and revamp safety measures, the nature of emergency preparation is reactionary rather than preemptive, says Mike Capulli, vice president of sales at GVI Security Solutions, a provider of video-surveillance security. After the Columbine shootings nearly 10 years ago, K-12 school districts woke up to the possibility of worst-case scenarios, Capulli says, while colleges "have been slow to respond."

John McNall, president of BowMac Educational Services, agrees. Administrators have realized for a long time that they need to upgrade emergency plans, McNall says; the Virginia Tech shootings were certainly another "'it can happen here' wake-up call." Christopher Blake, associate director at the International Association of Campus Law Enforcement Administrators, adds that developing better mass-notification systems via text-messaging is job one. Indeed, by the time Virginia Tech police had emailed students that a gunman was on the loose, many were already in class.

1,001 Things They Won't Tell You

1
2
Next

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS ETrade
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
Posted by: natale5boro
this country should invest in free tuition thats the way it is in Italy as well as universal health care Italy believes in investing in their young. as far as college is concerned its a waste if you don't have it. its a crime for our young people to come out of schoolimg with a load of debt. i could vomit at the money Bush and gang of rogues have squandered. and thanks to lawyers for making this world so paranoid. as a korean war vet i now believe our politicians are full of crap.
Posted by: chawk6of7
As a police officer at a major Big Ten university campus, I am not surprised to see some of these issues brought to the public -- especially the ones relating to money spent for security issues and university police officers' salaries.

However, I find it most interesting that many of the sources quoted for the personal safety issues are security consultants. While I'm not arguing that *some* places aren't providing the best practices for their students, I don't necessarily agree that the problem is as wide-spread as the consultants are claiming. After all, it is the consultants' business to create the concern so that people will hire them.
Posted by: stevof
As a college student, I generally still feel much safer on campus than in 95% of other settings.

Visit my financial blog at http://studentstocks.blogspot.com
Posted by: FVAQUER
Everyone wants better security on college campuses. Are parents and students willing to pay the higher taxes and higher tuition requiered to pay for increases in campus security?
Frederick Vaquer
Posted by: doonboggle
So what's the difference between colleges and elementary schools ... including inner-city schools?

NOTHING!!! Our elected officials, and appointed ones as well (think school administrator) are ALL letting us down when it comes to common sense. Makes one want to puke!!! And understand why one goes POSTAL....
Advertisements