Friday November 20, 2009 6:58 PM ET
SmartMoney
A A A
SmartMoney Magazine by Kelly Barron (Author Archive)

10 Things Veterinarians Won't Tell You

Below is an excerpt from the book "1,001 Things They Won't Tell You," which was published in May 2009 and highlights popular columns from SmartMoney's long-running "10 Things" feature.


1. “Good thing you love Sparky like a son. His care could cost as much.”

After a New York City taxi struck Jessica Malionek’s dog, Mojo, flinging him 30 feet in the air, she spent $4,000 for veterinarians to perform emergency treatment and then lifesaving surgeries on her beloved companion. “It was like they were treating a person,” Malionek says.

These days veterinary medicine can be every bit as sophisticated as human health care—and the costs reflect it. The amount of money that pet owners spend on vets is expected to have reached $10.8 billion in 2008, according to the American Pet Products Manufacturers Association. And per-visit costs are skyrocketing: From 2002 to 2006, the average cost of a veterinary visit for a dog rose from $172 to $219; for cats, from $133 to $172.

Why the steep price hikes? Chris Green, an attorney and member of the American Veterinary Medical Law Association, says vets are happily obliging owners who want to keep their pets alive at all costs. That means paying for the latest high-tech procedures, such as feline kidney transplants, cancer surgery for rabbits, CAT scans, and even MRIs. There are also more aged pets today, which require more care.

2. “Vaccinating your pet may do more harm than good.”

For years the primary reason for seeing a veterinarian was to get your pet vaccinated against a host of diseases ranging from distemper to rabies, either with individual vaccinations or “combo wombo” shots that could cover seven separate conditions. Indeed, annual vaccinations have been an economic bulwark for many vet practices. However, some veterinarians say they’re not only unnecessary but can actually be harmful in some cases. Marty Goldstein, a veterinarian in South Salem, N.Y., says he sees a range of vaccination-related reactions in animals, everything from cancerous sarcomas to epilepsy. Another reason to think twice about certain vaccines: The immunity provided by some of them can last well beyond a year and even as long as the pet’s lifetime, Goldstein says, negating the need for some annual shots.

Both the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) and the American Animal Hospital Association now say vaccinations should be assessed yearly and tailored to an animal’s age, health, and lifestyle. For example, an indoor cat with limited exposure to some diseases may not ever need certain common vaccinations, says W. Jean Dodds, an immunologist and veterinarian with Hemopet in Garden Grove, Calif. Only a veterinarian who has access to your pet’s complete medical history can determine which vaccinations should be administered and how they’ll be most effective. Also, talk with your vet if you’re considering traveling with your pet.

3. “I have more complaints filed against me than a used-car lot—not that you’ll ever know about it.”

When she picked up her kitten, Pumpkin, from the veterinarian after a routine spaying, Mount Pleasant, S.C., resident Marcia Rosenberg was stunned to find the cat nearly comatose. Soon Pumpkin’s body was wracked with seizures, and her stomach swelled. Rosenberg rushed Pumpkin to another vet, who saved the cat, but the distraught owner called her state’s veterinary board to complain. Told that the board had no procedure for alerting consumers about disciplinary actions taken against incompetent vets, Rosenberg mounted a successful campaign to have such actions posted on the South Carolina veterinary board’s website.

Tracking complaints against vets often requires a bit of detective work. Some state veterinary boards list disciplinary actions against vets, while others do not. And complaints typically aren’t disclosed until a board investigation and judicial ruling have determined a case of wrongdoing. On her own, Rosenberg says she was able to find that the veterinarian had previously had his license suspended in Ohio and since then had more than a dozen complaints against him in South Carolina.

1,001 Things They Won't Tell You

1
2
3
Next

Follow SmartMoney on Facebook, Twitter & More: Facebook Twitter
Bookmark and Share RSS
Order ReprintsOrder Reprints
User Comments
Posted by: WhatintheWorld
Since WHEN does it only cost $4,000 at a human hospital for someone hit by a car and flung 30 feet?!
rexholt

1 Comments

After reading the Kelly Barron story, I was quite frankly appalled and personally offended. The subtitle indicates the article will help tell you how to make sure you find appropriate care for your pet. Because of the format (and it is a Smart Money article), the reader gets the sense that there may be some cost savings or financial benefits as well. The article delivers neither. In fact it appears to be poorly researched and poorly understood and the conclusions drawn and recommendations given range from not very helpful to potentially very dangerous to the health of the pets. Almost all the so-called '10 points' made by this author are very biased and seem designed to pointedly blacken the eyes of the veterinary profession as a whole.
For instance, this article would lead you to think that reactions to routine pet vaccinations far outweigh the potential benefits to pet and owner. Let me be perfectly clear here, reaction rates to all commercial vaccines are extremely low. ...(Read more of this comment)

Thank you.

(Show less of this comment)
m_sametDVM

1 Comments
Cruella De Ville! Kelly Barron, you should be ashamed of yourself for your posture and inflammatory comments. You obviously haven't come across a good, compassionate veterinarian. My friends/colleagues and I are required to get as much as 32 credits of Continuing Education per year and know EVERYTHING about animal diseases in MULTIPLE species as well as the impact of these diseases on humans. Our clients call us sometimes several times a day with "another question that came up" and we actually pick up the phone and talk to them....please let me know the last time your MD got on the phone with you when you called! To boot we are a lot like pediatricians because our patients cannot communicate with us. However, Ms. Barron, you would have never taken on the Pediatricians for fear of the fallout. Every veterinarian I know went into this for love of animals and the profession. However, as a practice owner I can tell you that we have numerous bills to pay and we are allowed to make a living ...(Read more of this comment)
Lovethosedogs

1 Comments
Simply put, for the care that veterinarians provide, they are extremely reasonable.

The last time I was at my own doctor (lip laceration that required a local anesthetic and 4 stitches and some antibiotics)...........$500.

The last trip to my veterinarian (dog ate socks and they obstructed his small intestines..........general anesthesia, portion of small intestines removed because the tissue was dead/dying, hospitalized care for 2 days, some pain meds and some antibiotics..........$750

I probably could have let my superficial lacetation heal on it's own. Without care at the vet, my dog would have died.

To top it off, I called ahead in both cases for an appointment. I waited a total of 3 hours to even begin to talk to my doctor. I waited 10 minutes at my vet even though an emergency (dog that was hit by a car) came in right before me. 30 minutes later, a small amount of bloodwork was already done and the x-rays were developed and we knew what t...(Read more of this comment)
Posted by: grrrrrutah
I was dismayed as I read this article. I have to assume that Kelly Barron intended to educate the public as to ensuring that they get their "dollar's worth" at the veterinarian's office. However, despite approaching the article with the thought of giving benefit of the doubt and consciously striving to be objective, I felt that the general tone of the article was actually condescending to those in the veterinary profession. I also felt that while several legitimate statements were relayed via this article, rather than encouraging pet owners to be proactive and educate themselves regarding their pet's health care, it encouraged them to be on the defensive from the time they step over the threshold of their local clinic. Personal experiences may have formed the statements made by the persons interiviewed for this article, but the majority of veterinary professionals' professional behavior and opinions were definitely NOT represented.

What may be more beneficial to owners and v...(Read more of this comment)
Advertisements